By Kent Holsinger, Contributing Editor
On March 3, 2009, the U.S. Supreme Court issued a 5-4 opinion in
Summers v. Earth Island Institute, et. al. Plaintiffs, five
environmental groups, challenged a 238 acre salvage timber sale in the
Seqoia National Forest. Citing the “proper--and properly limited--role
of the courts in a democratic society,” Justice Scalia delivered the
majority opinion which held plaintiffs had no standing to challenge the
U.S. Forest Service regulations absent a showing of a concrete injury
related to a particular project.